Why you keep getting sore

Mike Collette • July 20, 2020

By: Mike Collette (Owner of Prototype Training Systems)

A member asked me in an email:

“How do you determine when it’s too many days per week aka overtraining? Sometimes I feel like it’s helpful to come in really sore and get things moving and other times I do that and I feel completely drained…not sure if it’s age-related but lately I’m having a hard time telling the difference between good soreness and overtraining…”


This is such a good question and something we get asked quite a bit at Prototype so as part of my 30 Days of content challenge, I wanted to address this!

I used to think that being sore was the only way to tell if you got an effective workout or not. Remember the phrase back in high school, “no pain, no gain!”? That certainly applies to the concept that if you workout, you should be sore afterward. But the question I want to propose to you is if you workout and you’re not sore, was it a good workout?


There are a 5 major things I want to here:


1.) What is soreness? What is DOMS?

2.) The SAID Principle

3.) Repetitive Strain

4.) Rest

5.) Additional factors


To give you some context into what soreness is, it’s ultimately a response your body gives you that your muscles have broken down and you have done something it hasn’t accommodated to. After we exercise, we can create microscopic tears/damage to our soft tissue. That damage can potentially cause soreness. Typically, after you work out or the days following, that soreness is referred to as DOMS (Delayed Onset Muscle Soreness). DOMS can last a day or two or even up to 5 depending on the level of stress you put on your body!


There is more than stress/strain that goes into soreness as well. It ultimately comes down to the SAID principle which stands for Specific Adaptation to Imposed Demands. The SAID principle, simply put, is that your body adapts to the stress that you put on it. So the more repetitive, consistent stress you put on your body, your body is resilient enough to adapt to it, not giving you the same response gradually.

The easiest way to think of this is running. If you run 1 mile at the same pace every day, it might be hard the first few times and you may be sore the first few times. However, over time your body will be used to it. But if you turn up the speed, add in hills or change your tempo, doing something your body may not be used to, it can feel differently.

Another example of how soreness works is a personal one. I workout 5 days per week and do some pretty intense training at Prototype. I lift weights, run, jump, sprint, jog… basically movements that would enhance my athletic capability. But I can go play 3 hours of basketball and the next day I may not be able to walk because I’m so sore. Did I look like LeBron James out on the court? Probably not. Did I work and do something that my body isn’t used to? Definitely. Am I sore? You bet. Why? BECAUSE I NEVER PLAY BASKETBALL!


A better example that you may be able to relate to is if you do 100 Wall ball shots (everyone’s nemesis!) your body may or may not be sore the next day. You will most likely be sore if you do 100 wall ball shots in a row. You may not be as sore if you do 10 sets of 10 wall ball shots with :20-:30 seconds rest between each set. You may even feel completely fine the next day! The same total volume, same exercise, and heck, the 10×10 may take you just as long to do 100 wall ball shots without resting! 


The concept here is the repetitive strain without rest. Rest ultimately is what allows your body to recover (that’s why sleep is so important!).
These workouts, even though they’re the same, the strain is different. Your body responds differently to volume. If you’re not used to doing 50 wall ball shots in a row without rest, your body hasn’t accommodated to that type of stimulus and it may respond with some more than normal soreness.


So how do you know what is good soreness and when you may need to rest more? I hate these responses but ultimately the answer is, it depends. Being sore is a response, not necessarily a bad thing. However, if your body is constantly aching, fatigued, tired and chronically in pain then something else may be going on. The concept of “overtraining” gets thrown around a lot with chronic soreness and overuse. 


Overtraining is essentially a physiological state caused by an excess accumulation of physical, psychological, emotional, environmental, and chemical stress. The good news is you’re probably not overtraining. In fact, it’s really hard to over train. There are Olympic athletes that train 20+ hours a week and don’t overtrain. If you’re training 4-6 hours per week you’re more than likely totally fine, just focus on your sleep and recovery!


What may be the issue is how you’re recovering from your training sessions and as a result, you’re overtaxing yourself. Some additional factors that relate to increases in soreness from your workouts outside of sleep and rest are:


1.) Hydration-Dehydration

2.) Nutrition

3.) Additional stressors


So you need to ask yourself a few questions: 


Are you giving your body the TLC it deserves after those 1 hour intense training sessions/workouts? 


Are you getting 7-8 hours of sleep a night?


Are you eating enough food throughout the day? How about your protein intake?


Are you drinking enough water throughout the day? Especially on the hot ones!


Are you doing a lot of unstructured physical activity that is causing more strain than you realize on your body?


Are you drinking too much alcohol? THIS PLAYS A MAJOR ROLE IN SORENESS!
Those are a lot of questions, but outside of the actual training session, there are additional factors that you need to consider.


Looking to improve your recovery? Talk to one of your coaches today to get the best prescription for you with a free goal review session. We are here to help and serve you the best we can, just ask! Use the link below to talk with a coach today!

Previous Blogs

Prototype Ai Master Coach

Chasing Consistency: How Building an AI Coach is Refining Our Human Coaching

By Mike Collette • April 24, 2025
How we are using Ai at Prototype and how its just beginning

Developing Young Leaders: Why Competition Matters

By Mike Collette • April 16, 2025
Yesterday was a great reminder of what a little friendly competition can do. We set up a simple 1-v-1 game: kids had to sprint, tap two cones, and race back to knock over a foam roller. Nothing fancy, just movement, focus, and a clear goal. But something cool happened. The second it became head-to-head, the energy shifted. Kids were locked in. They ran harder. They pushed themselves—not because they were told to, but because someone else was giving it their all too. Even the kids watching got invested—shouting encouragement, clapping for effort, reacting to every close finish. That sense of shared experience, of community rooted in challenge, is exactly what youth development should be about. It was a perfect example of how competition, even in its simplest form, can bring out motivation and effort . Not for a prize, but just for the challenge of it. More Than a Game: The Real Value of Friendly Competition In today’s world of participation medals and well-meaning “everyone wins” culture, it’s easy to misunderstand the role of competition. But when designed thoughtfully and guided with intention, competition doesn’t diminish self-worth—it enhances it. According to a 2019 study published in Frontiers in Psychology, structured competition can lead to higher intrinsic motivation, improved self-esteem, and a greater sense of personal accomplishment in youth participants (Bonfiglio et al., 2019). When kids compete, they learn that effort yields results. They learn how to win graciously—and perhaps more importantly—how to lose with resilience. They discover the value of hard work, discipline, and focus. They get to ask: “How fast can I be?” “How far can I push myself?” And, “What happens if I try just a little harder?” The Pride in Performance There’s a moment—right after a child finishes a race, or a round of a competitive game—where they catch their breath, stand a little taller, and smile. Whether they won or not is almost secondary. What matters is that they showed up and gave their best effort. That sense of pride? That’s not vanity. It’s the birth of confidence. And when that confidence is built through movement, through play, through sweating and trying and doing—it sticks. Not just in sport, but in school, at home, in friendships, and beyond. Final Thoughts Competition, when framed the right way, helps kids build confidence, stay motivated, and take pride in their effort. It’s not about winning — it’s about showing up, trying hard, and learning what they’re capable of. At its best, competition doesn’t separate kids — it brings them together, showing them how to push themselves while supporting each other along the way.

Stress, Money, and Your Health: How to Make Better Decisions in Uncertain Times

By Mike Collette • April 10, 2025
It’s no secret — we’re living in a world that feels increasingly volatile. Financial markets are unpredictable. The news cycle is overwhelming, social media noise is constant and it's harder and harder to sort through what's real and what's not. And when uncertainty rises, it's human nature for people to start making emotional decisions. Being in the fitness industry for close to 20 years and operating Prototype Training Systems since 2012, I've seen this happen time and time again — not just in the stock market — but in our gym community. When we feel stressed financially (and trust me, i've been there as an entrepreneur), one of the first things they often cut is their investment in their health. Cancelling the gym. Skipping workouts. Pressing pause on coaching or training. We can go into a frenzy of what needs to be prioritized and what doesn't, and often it's rooted in anxiety and fear. On the surface, it makes sense: "Let me tighten up my budget until things feel safer." But here’s the truth — it’s completely backwards . Emotional Decisions Rarely Lead to Positive Outcomes In a recent conversation I had with Brendan Sheehan, founder of Waymark Wealth Management (and one of our community business sponsors), we talked about this exact thing. As we are facing that uncertainty now in the market. Click the link to listen to the full podcast! Brendan was sharing when the market drops — whether it’s 5%, 10%, or more — people panic. But the data shows this happens all the time. He shared that "the m arket dips of 5-10% happens three times a year on average." Dips of 10-20%? Happens at least once a year. It’s not unusual — but when emotions take over, we make decisions that can hurt long-term. And this same pattern can show up in health and fitness. Your Health is Not a Luxury — It’s Essential Let’s be real — when life feels hard, stressful, or uncertain, you need your health more than ever. Exercise isn't just about aesthetics or performance — it's your anchor. Working out helps you regulate stress, sleep better, stay clear-headed, and avoid the emotional roller coaster that uncertainty brings. Cutting your health investments when things get tough is like saying: "The storm is coming... so I'm going to throw away my umbrella." It doesn’t make sense, but this what happens when emotions are high, it's REALLY hard to make logical decisions. We can get into a binary mode of thinking... then we take action which often isn't fully thought out. The Vicious Cycle: Stress → Cut Health → Decline → Regret Here's the common pattern we’ve seen over the years... and I would argue is common in every gym across the country... Things get tough financially or emotionally. We go into "panic" mode... start to take action. People cut their gym membership or stop exercising. Maybe you over narrate it's not worth it... maybe you over narrate I'll just do it on my own and change my entire routine... or maybe you think it will only be very short term. Then, stress increases. Energy drops. Sleep gets worse. Health declines — physically and mentally. Time passes... regret kicks in. "I wish I hadn't stopped. Now it’s even harder to get back ." Sound familiar? It's a vicious cycle and REALLY hard to break. We’ve seen it over and over — and we’ve helped people climb back out of it. But we’d rather help you avoid that spiral in the first place. What Should You Do Instead? Have faith in your routine and take a second to pause before making a major life change. Double down on habits that ground you — like fitness, community, and nutrition. Talk to a coach. Share what’s stressing you out — we’re here to help. Be curious — ask questions before making big decisions. Remember: health is not the problem — it’s the solution. Final Thought: Uncertainty will always be part of life. Markets go up and down. Challenges will come and go. But the best investment you can make — in any economy — is in your physical and mental well-being. At Prototype Training Systems, we’re more than a gym. We’re a community that helps people stay grounded, consistent, and healthy — no matter what’s happening outside our walls. If you’re feeling the pull to cut your health in hard times — let’s talk. Book a Free Goal Review Session with a coach... seriously, we're here to help. We’ll help you navigate uncertainty the right way — by staying strong, staying consistent, and investing in yourself.
More Posts

Climb to New Heights

Prototype Training Systems is more than a gym - it is a lifestyle. Join us today!

Book Free No-Sweat Intro